[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

[DNA] Issue 7: Clarify Goal 7 SEND/IPsec Compatability



Dear DNA WG 
 
This is an attempt to resolve this issue:

Issue 7 
Jari Arkko proposed to clarify G7. 

G7. DNA schemes should be compatible with security schemes such as 
     Secure Neighbour Discovery [8] and IPSec [7].

  "I understand the SEND part. Not sure I understand the IPsec
   part. ... perhaps you could clarify what your requirement is"   

Suggested resolution: We propose to remove IPSec part as below.

   G7. DNA schemes should be compatible with security schemes such as
      Secure Neighbour Discovery [7].

Because DNA will be based on ND, SEND will be sufficient and, 
as Jari commented, IPsec part can cause unnecessary ambiguities 
with little benefit. 

Please register your opinion if you have any comments, otherwise 
we'll update the goals draft accordingly and move it forward.
 
Thanks to Greg's kind work, we now have the issue list at 
 
http://ctieware.eng.monash.edu.au/twiki/bin/view/DNA/DNAGoals
 
Thanks for your kind consideration. 
 
Best Regards
 
JinHyeock